“Second-Guessing, and Feeding the Soul,” column for Oct. 29, 2013

Have you ever made a decision you felt sure was right, only to end up wondering later: What was I thinking?

Second guessing. I hate it.

Recently, I left my home and my husband and the life that I love, to spend some time alone working on a novel on a lake in the mountains where I grew up.

When I made that decision, and most days since, I felt good about it. But there are moments when I have my doubts.

This is one of them.

I blame my grandmothers. You’d be hardpressed to find two women with less in common, apart from the facts that they both married, raised children and loved their grandchildren. Especially me.

But at some point in their later years _ the point at which, to my utter amazement, I now seem to find myself _ they chose vastly different lifestyles.

One lived alone in the quiet of a mountain where she took great delight in birds and books and sunsets and seasons and the occasional visits from her family. Especially me.

The other lived on the main street of town in a never-ending drama of nine grown daughters, where she knew everybody’s business and how much they paid for it, and doted on her grandchildren. Especially me.

The best moments of my childhood were spent in the care of those two women. I will forever be in their debt.

However, I somehow ended up with both of their natures, not necessarily their better sides. I don’t mean a combination of their various traits. I mean two distinctly different characters, the flip sides of one coin.

I like spending time alone.

But I like, just as much, to be absolutely in the thick of things.

I feel equally at home on a city street or a pig trail on the back of a mountain. Preferably a pig trail with an all-night diner.

I love having my house full of people, cooking for a crowd, watching them eat, listening to the music of their laughter.

And after they’re gone, I’m happy to be alone again, to take a deep breath and clean up the mess and give thanks for the good times we shared.

The problem is this: I don’t want just one or the other; I want both _ to be alone, and to be with the people I love.

Too much of one leaves me homesick for the other.

The key, I suppose, as with most things in life, is balance.

This evening, I stood staring into a half-empty fridge, hoping to find something to eat without having to drive into town.

I was getting hungrier by the minute, for more than just food. I missed my husband. My kids. My grandkids. I even missed their dogs. And for what? To sit alone on a lake, trying to finish a book that would probably never matter to any living soul but me? What was I thinking?

Why do we always have to choose one love over another?

That last question _ spoken aloud to a refrigerator _ is one I’ve been asking most of my life.

The first time was when I was about 4 years old, soon after my parents divorced. My mountain grandmother dried my eyes with her apron and tried to explain why I could no longer live with both my mother and my dad in the same house together.

“We can’t always have things both ways,” she said. “But we can enjoy them one at a time.”

Her meaning might have been lost on me back then, but today, somehow, it found me.

So I took whatever I had on hand _ potatoes, carrots, onions and kale _ and roasted it in the oven with a little olive oil and a lot of garlic. And I ate it on the porch overlooking the lake in the waning, golden light of a perfect autumn day.

It was good.

Then I went back inside and sat down to write.

Sometimes the best meal, the one we truly hunger for, is the one that feeds our soul.


  1. I can understand why a writer needs lonely time as only quite time can give us so many new ideas to put in words . You are an awesome writer and many many generations will read your book . Blessings and enjoy any peaceful time even at home and if need arises go out on a vacation out of town close to mountains ,close to birds where you will see your heart is singing with them . Love your articles ,love each paragraph and do not want to stop till end in one sitting .

  2. Kate Sciacca says

    Thanks Sharon for sharing your insights. I too love both…. Being with my 8 kids, their spouses (4 of mine are married) and all the grandkids. But when it is quiet, and I have cleaned up after the last toddler, I enjoy that awesome quiet, when I can pray and thank God for the blessings He has bestowed on me…. And cry, not tears of sadness, but tears of joy. :-). BTW, I live in the “other Nevada” – Carson City – a wee bit nicer than Sin City. 😉

  3. sydney love says

    You have done it again! I think sometimes when I don’t know which foot to put forward next, God sends you as the messenger. The things that you wrote in this article are exactly the way I feel but can never put it into words. That is exactly why I can’t wait to read your book, so don’t quit, don’t ever quit.

  4. Naomi Smith says

    Another good column. And just wanted to tell you that your book will matter to lots of us who love your writing and you.

  5. Angela Vandiver says

    How blessed I am to get to read your wonderful words. I feel as though you jump into my heart, pull out all the things that I feel, and put them on paper! Every week when I read your column I am so encouraged and inspired. I also am a Christian, wife, mother, grandmother, sister, and a friend. I believe I am the most blessed woman alive. I am blessed even more because of you and your writing. Thank you for what you do. Angela

  6. Rick Carter says

    What a great quote from your “mountain grandmother!” And just for the record Sharon, your book does matter!

  7. Amen, Sharon! Thanks for the inspiration. For the record, I am looking forward to reading your novel.

    All the best,


  8. Marian (Rudolph) Nelson says

    Oh yes, dear Sharon, you do “get it”. I’m Ginny’s bookie friend, and as I look at my “new” life, after losing my husband of 50 years and remarrying (an old friend), I’ve been considering writing a book as well. I think I’ll call it Chapter 2, because it is a new chapter of an old story. Perhaps it’s the woman/mother in us, but we do want it all , the families, the alone time, the romance of new experience, the joys of watching our children and grandchildren growing and marrying and allowing us to be part of it too. I look forward to the “feast” of reading your new book!

Speak Your Mind